By 
Microsoft Copilot Studio is evolving fast, and with it comes a feature that fundamentally changes how we test, measure, and trust AI responses. That feature is the Evaluation Tool in Copilot.
If you have ever built a Copilot agent and wondered whether it consistently gives accurate, relevant, and grounded responses, you already know the problem. Until recently, testing Copilot meant running manual prompts again and again, tracking results by hand, and hoping nothing broke when data or instructions changed.
The Copilot Evaluation Engine fixes that.
In this article, we’ll walk through what the Evaluation Tool in Copilot is, why it matters, and how you can use it to validate Copilot behavior at scale. This guide is based on a real walkthrough from my YouTube tutorial and is written for SharePoint admins, Microsoft 365 developers, and Copilot builders who want reliable, production-ready AI agents.
What Is the Evaluation Tool in Copilot?
The Evaluation Tool in Copilot is a built-in testing and validation feature inside Microsoft Copilot Studio. It allows you to automatically assess how well your Copilot agent responds to predefined questions and scenarios.
Instead of manually testing prompts one by one, you can now:
- Define test datasets
- Run evaluations in bulk
- Measure response quality
- Detect regressions when your data or instructions change
This brings a much-needed engineering mindset to Copilot development. You are no longer guessing whether your Copilot works. You are measuring it.
Why Copilot Evaluation Matters More Than Ever
Copilot agents are increasingly used for:
- Internal knowledge search
- HR and policy Q&A
- SharePoint document discovery
- IT helpdesk automation
- Business process guidance
In these scenarios, a wrong answer is not just inconvenient. It can be risky.
Before the Copilot evaluation engine, most teams relied on:
- Manual testing
- Limited spot checks
- Informal validation
That approach doesn’t scale.
The Evaluation Tool in Copilot introduces repeatable, consistent testing, which is critical when:
- You upload new files
- You change system prompts
- You connect new data sources
- You deploy Copilot to production users
Where to Find the Evaluation Tool in Copilot Studio
Inside Microsoft Copilot Studio, the Evaluation feature appears directly within your Copilot agent.
From your agent:
- Open the Agent menu
- Expand the navigation panel
- Select Evaluation
This menu is available for agents that support file uploads and knowledge grounding, which makes it especially useful for enterprise Copilot scenarios.
How to create test set in Copilot Studio?
From the evaluation menu, click on the “+ New test set” button.
Then, this will you take you to new test set creation screen.
We can create a new test set multiple ways:
- By uploading a CSV file, you can download the template and fill in your own data..
- Generate 10 questions—create questions that are based on the agent’s description, instruction, and capabilities.
- Use your test chat conversation—gather the inputs and responses from your current manual testing session.
- Manually add—create your own test cases manually.
Already I have created a test set with the 10 test cases using the AI to generate 10 questions, and below is the evaluation summary result. Watch the detailed demo from my YouTube video tutorial in the below section.
How the Copilot Evaluation Engine Works
At a high level, the Copilot Studio testing framework follows a simple but powerful model.
1. Define Evaluation Data
You start by providing a set of questions or prompts. These represent the types of queries your users are expected to ask.
Examples:
- What is our company leave policy?
- How do I request access to SharePoint?
- Summarize this uploaded document
These questions act as your test cases.
2. Upload Knowledge Sources
The evaluation runs against your Copilot’s configured data:
- Uploaded files
- SharePoint content
- Websites
- Other connected sources
This ensures the Copilot evaluation is grounded in the same data your real users rely on.
Read Also:
With Copilot Studio How to Upload Multiple Files to SharePoint Instantly in 7 Steps
3. Run the Evaluation
Once configured, you run the evaluation in bulk. Copilot processes every question and generates responses automatically.
No manual prompting.
No copy-paste testing.
No guesswork.
4. Review Evaluation Results
This is where the Evaluation Tool in Copilot really shines.
You can review:
- Accuracy of responses
- Relevance to the question
- Grounding to source data
- Consistency across runs
These insights help you understand whether your Copilot is actually production-ready.
Evaluation vs Manual Copilot Testing
Let’s be clear. Manual testing still has value, but it has limits.
| Manual Testing | Copilot Evaluation Tool |
|---|---|
| Time-consuming | Automated |
| Hard to repeat | Fully repeatable |
| Subjective | Measurable |
| Doesn’t scale | Designed for scale |
The Evaluation Tool in Copilot is not meant to replace exploration. It is meant to support quality assurance.
Real-World Use Case: File-Based Copilot Agents
In the video tutorial, the Evaluation Tool is demonstrated using a file upload Copilot agent.
This scenario is extremely common:
- Upload policy documents
- Upload training manuals
- Upload internal knowledge files
Using the evaluation engine, you can:
- Verify that Copilot answers strictly from uploaded files
- Detect hallucinations
- Ensure answers don’t drift after updates
This is especially important for compliance-driven organizations.
Key Benefits of Using the Evaluation Tool in Copilot
1. Confidence Before Production
You can validate Copilot responses before rolling out to users.
2. Faster Iteration
Change prompts, re-run evaluation, compare results. No waiting.
3. Reduced Risk
Fewer incorrect or ungrounded answers in real usage.
4. Better Governance
Evaluation results support internal reviews and approvals.
Best Practices for Copilot Evaluation
To get the most from the Microsoft Copilot Studio evaluation feature, follow these best practices.
Use Real User Questions
Don’t invent questions. Use actual queries from emails, tickets, or chats.
Test Edge Cases
Include vague, incomplete, or ambiguous questions.
Re-Evaluate After Changes
Any data update should trigger a new evaluation run.
Keep Evaluation Sets Updated
Your business evolves. Your test data should too.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Testing with too few questions
- Ignoring evaluation results
- Assuming one successful run is enough
- Treating evaluation as optional
If Copilot is critical to your workflow, evaluation is not optional.
How Evaluation Improves Copilot Trust
Trust in AI doesn’t come from demos. It comes from consistency.
The Copilot evaluation engine provides:
- Evidence
- Metrics
- Repeatability
That’s how Copilot moves from experiment to enterprise tool.
Watch the Full Video Tutorial
For a complete step-by-step walkthrough of the Evaluation Tool in Copilot, watch the video tutorial here:
👉 YouTube Tutorial:
The video shows the actual Copilot Studio interface, menu navigation, and evaluation execution in real time.
Final Thoughts
The Evaluation Tool in Copilot is one of the most important features Microsoft has added to Copilot Studio.
If you are serious about:
- Building reliable Copilot agents
- Reducing AI risk
- Scaling Copilot across your organization
Then evaluation should be part of your standard development process.
Copilot is powerful. Evaluation makes it trustworthy.
See Also
About Post Author
